# Competitive Analysis

**Date:** November 2, 2025  
**Status:** ✅ Updated with Runware + ImageKit research  
**Version:** 1.0

---

## Key Competitors

### Runware AI ($13M funding)
- **Price:** $0.0006/image (166x cheaper than us)
- **Positioning:** Infrastructure play (AWS approach)
- **Target:** High-volume, price-sensitive buyers
- **Gaps:** No prompt enhancement, no consistency, REST only

### ImageKit.io (Enterprise scale)
- **Price:** $0.10-0.25/image effective
- **Feature:** URL-based generation (validates Prompt URLs concept)
- **Target:** E-commerce, marketing teams
- **Gaps:** No prompt enhancement, no @references, no developer tools

### Inference Infrastructure (Commodity)
- fal.ai: $0.028/image
- Replicate: $0.03/image
- Together.ai: Similar
- **Positioning:** Raw compute, no pipeline

### Manual Tools
- Midjourney: $0.05/image, Discord workflow, no API
- DALL-E: Via OpenAI, no consistency

---

## Our Competitive Advantages

### 1. Prompt Enhancement (PRIMARY MOAT)
- Generic → Professional quality
- 3-6 months to replicate
- Always enabled, not optional
- This is what justifies $0.10 vs $0.0006

### 2. Consistency System (@references)
- Style/object persistence across generations
- Unique feature, no competitor has this
- Post-MVP (needs validation)

### 3. Production Pipeline
- CDN delivery included
- 6 aspect ratios built-in
- Transformations (with focal point detection)
- Zero manual work

### 4. Developer Experience
- MCP (Cursor/Claude Code)
- SDK (programmatic)
- CLI (terminal)
- Prompt URLs (universal)

---

## Positioning vs Competitors

**NOT competing on price:**
- Runware = infrastructure ($0.0006)
- Us = DX premium ($0.10)

**Analogy:**
- Runware = AWS S3 (cheap storage)
- Us = Vercel (developer experience)

**Effective cost comparison:**

| Solution | List Price | Hidden Costs | Effective Total |
|----------|-----------|--------------|-----------------|
| Runware | $0.0006 | CDN setup, transformations, prompting, 10 min manual | $4-25/image |
| Banatie | $0.10 | Zero | $0.10/image |

**Target different buyers:**
- Runware: Infrastructure teams, volume buyers
- ImageKit: E-commerce, marketing teams
- Banatie: AI developers, web agencies

---

## Why We Win

### vs Runware:
- Quality layer (enhancement)
- Complete solution (not just generation)
- Developer workflow (MCP, SDK, CLI)

### vs ImageKit:
- Developer-first (not marketing-first)
- Prompt enhancement (not generic)
- @references consistency (unique)

### vs Midjourney:
- Automation (API vs Discord)
- Integration (MCP vs manual)
- Speed (instant vs 5-10 min workflow)

---

## Free Tier Strategy

**NOT competing with free:**
- OpenRouter: 50/day free
- Google AI Studio: 500-1000/day free
- Combined: 16K-31K/month free

**Our free tier = testing only:**
- 10 images/month with watermark
- All features included
- Goal: Prove quality, convert to paid

**Paid tier = production use:**
- Data privacy (not used for training)
- Professional quality (enhancement)
- Production features (CDN, transformations)
- Support

**Messaging:**
> "Free tier = hobby projects, generic quality.
> Paid tier = professional work, client-ready quality."

---

**Last updated:** November 2, 2025  
**Next review:** After 10 customer interviews